10 Ideas to Grow Your Food Brand's Email List

Email Marketing Expert

Posted By Peyton Fox | October 24th, 2023

With the rise of ecommerce and online spending, email marketing remains a powerful strategy for businesses to connect and interact with their audience. For food brands, building a solid email list requires thorough planning, nurturing, and the right ingredients. In this blog post, we will explore some creative, practical, and effective ideas to help your food brand email list see continued growth.

1. Popup Email Signup

Popup email signups are an effective method to grow your food brand’s email list. A popup is a small window that appears on a website and overlays existing content, aiming to capture attention and nudge people to take action– in this case, we want them to subscribe to your email list. 

If the look of your popup doesn’t look good or feels too pushy, it won’t garner any clicks. Make sure the popup is friendly, visually appealing, easy to close, and offers something like a discount, free recipe, or template. Images can increase email signups by 63.49%, So customize the popup to match your brand’s message and aesthetic, and choose the best colors, fonts, and images that align best with your brand’s identity. 

Timing is also key to getting the most out of your popups. Time your popups carefully; we don’t want to have a popup show up with every click or if they refresh the page- the goal is to be enticing- not annoying. Exit-intent popups, for example, trigger when someone is about to leave your site and can be particularly effective. 

Popup email signups are a useful tool for growing your food brand’s email list. When you create your popup- make sure to take timing and looks into account; create a popup that matches your brand’s look and has a friendly, approachable feel to it. When used strategically and thoughtfully, popups can greatly boost your subscriber count and foster a loyal customer base for your food brand.

Grow Your Food Brand Example 1

2. Create Interactive Quizzes/Content

Have a little fun and create something to get subscribers to interact with your brand. Interactive content is twice as likely to engage a visitor as static content.

Interactive quizzes and content are a great way to do this because it allows you to connect with your audience and gather valuable insights into their preferences. People love participating and sharing their results; create entertaining interactive quizzes related to food, recipes, cooking tips, or even what kind of product a customer might be. 

Quizzes also enable you to collect data about customer preferences and cooking habits. The data collected gives insights into your customers, which can then be used to create targeted content and personalized offers. 

Offer social sharing to expand your brand’s reach, especially with quizzes, as people love sharing their results with friends and family. When quiz participants share their results, they introduce your brand to their social circles, potentially bringing new visitors to your website. Include social share buttons and catchy prompts to nudge users to share their quiz outcomes, increasing visibility and potential email signups.

By incorporating interactive quizzes and content into your marketing strategy, you create an engaging experience and establish a connection with potential subscribers. When people share their quiz results on social media, knowledge of your brand spreads, reaching new corners of the internet and drawing in curious minds.

Grow Your Food Brand Example 2

3. Educational Content

Learning can be fun! Offer an educational incentive to grab your audience’s attention. By offering educational content it shows that your brand is knowledgeable in the food industry and attracts subscribers interested in learning more. Some examples of things to provide include cooking tutorials, nutrition guides, or behind-the-scenes glimpses into your process. By providing educational information, you foster trust with your audience, encouraging them to subscribe for more insightful updates.

When your brand provides valuable information, your customers see your brand as trustworthy and reliable. People are more likely to subscribe to emails from a brand they trust, increasing your email list. Create your content to provide valuable solutions and nudge your audience to subscribe to your email list for tutorials, in-depth guides, or exclusive recipes.

Grow Your Food Brand Example 3

4. Offer Limited-Time Freebies

Who doesn’t love freebies? Offering limited-time freebies is a great way to grow your food brand’s email list. It works by attracting possible customers with time-sensitive offers in exchange for their email addresses. When people receive something for free, they are more likely to reciprocate by providing their contact information. Some freebie examples include downloadable recipes, cooking tips and tricks, or access to cooking webinars.

Limited-time freebies create a sense of urgency and excitement. When people know they have a short window to access something valuable for free, it urges them to act quickly. This urgency prompts them to subscribe to your email list to receive the offer before it expires.

Grow Your Food Brand Example 4

5. Collaborate With Influencers

Get active in the community by collaborating with influencers. This can be a great strategy to grow your food brand’s email list. Influencers, particularly those who focus their content around food, have dedicated followers who trust their suggestions. When these influencers support your brand and encourage their followers to subscribe to your email list, you tap into an active and engaged audience that is more likely to transform into loyal customers. 

Influencers tend to have a broad reach on social media platforms. Use this to your advantage and work with food-related influencers to promote your brand and email list, allowing your brand to gain exposure to a larger audience. 

 Take the opportunity to collaborate with food influencers. Their promotion of your brand can increase your email list and build a community of devoted customers who are eager to be a part of your food brand’s journey. The key lies in being authentic and genuine- qualities that influencers bring to the table, making this strategy not just useful but also significant for the long-term growth of your food brand.

Grow Your Food Brand Example 5

6. Social Media

When in doubt- always turn to social media. Social media platforms allow you to showcase your food brand to the world. Post regularly and include engaging content, entertaining videos, and high-quality images related to your products to attract and keep the attention of potential customers. Include a catchy CTA in your social media posts, encouraging users to subscribe to your email list for exclusive content. You can also leverage social media subscribers by encouraging them to join your list as a VIP to gain early access to promotions, product launches, and exclusive deals. 

Platforms like Facebook and Instagram even offer advertising to reach specific demographics interested in food and cooking. Create visually appealing ads that also offer an incentive in exchange for subscribing to your email list. Social media platforms allow you to hone in on your target audience, ensuring your ads are shown to possible subscribers.

Let your existing customers do some work for you by sharing their experiences with your products on social media using a branded hashtag. Share any user-generated content, such as positive reviews, testimonials, and social proof you receive on your social media profiles, and acknowledge that you appreciate your customers. This can bring more people to your email list and also help create a sense of community around your brand. 

By using social media and user-generated data, you can effectively grow your food brand’s email list, creating a community of engaged subscribers who are genuinely interested in your products and content. This isn’t a one-time thing; remember to consistently provide content and engage with your audience to create compelling incentives to encourage social media users to become valuable email subscribers.

Grow Your Food Brand Example 6

7. Refer-A-Friend Program

People love to talk about their experiences; if someone loves your brand- chances are they will tell their family and friends about it. A Refer-a-Friend program can be a great way to grow your food brand’s email list. This strategy uses your existing customer base as advocates for your brand, inspiring them to spread the word about your brand and incentivizing their friends and family to join your email community. 

Referrals from friends tend to be trusted more than advertisements. 82% of Americans say they seek recommendations from friends and family when considering a purchase. By having your existing customers vouch for your brand, you build trust and credibility among potential subscribers.

To motivate your existing customers to refer others, offer incentives for both the referrer and the referee, like a free product, discount, or loyalty points for each successful referral. Similarly, give the new subscriber a welcome discount or a special offer to thank them for joining the email list. These incentives mutually benefit all parties and encourage more people to participate.

A Refer-a-Friend program can be a highly effective and efficient way to grow your food brand’s email list. By using the trust and influence of your existing customers and providing incentives, you can expand your brand’s reach, build credibility, and create a community of engaged subscribers.

Grow Your Food Brand Example 7

8. Blog Posts

An effective email marketing strategy that can often remain overlooked is making blog content on your website. But how does this aid in growing your email list? This approach can be used with other email marketing tactics to create compelling content informing customers about your food brand.

By offering valuable insights, recipes, and stories about your culinary journey, you establish your brand as a prominent source for food lovers. Sharing narratives about your sourcing trips and the passionate individuals crafting your creations humanizes your brand, fostering a genuine connection with your audience. As visitors explore your blog, they’re invited to exchange their email addresses for exclusive, high-quality content, including weekly blog posts featuring enticing recipes and cooking hacks.

Your blog can also become a window into the content of your newsletters. This strategy enhances the reader experience and promotes a dedicated community around your food brand. It all begins with a simple yet irresistible action: subscribing to your exclusive email list. You create a seamless and engaging experience through these combined methods, encouraging visitors to stay connected, informed, and inspired by your brand. Need some more guidance about how blog posts can benefit your food brands email list? Check out our blog and see what blog posting can do for your food brand!

Grow Your Food Brand Example 8

9. Create A Loyalty Program

 Studies show that 43% of customers worldwide tend to spend more money on brands they are loyal to so creating a loyalty program is a strategic and effective way to grow your food brand’s email list while fostering customer loyalty. A well-designed loyalty program can encourage repeat purchases, growth in customer engagement, and spread brand awareness. 

Offer exclusive access to new products or unique discounts to customers who join your loyalty program and subscribe to your email list. You’re more likely to convert one-time buyers into long-term subscribers and loyal customers by incentivizing them to feel appreciated. 

Try a points system, where customers earn points for every purchase, social media engagement, or referral. Customers can use these points and redeem them for discounts, free products, or other rewards. To get all these good deals, customers can be required to sign up for your email newsletter, which then expands your email list while creating a loyal customer base. 

By using a combination of exclusive offers, personalized rewards, and community engagement, your food brand can create a loyal customer base while expanding your reach through an ever-growing email list.

Grow Your Food Brand Example 9

10. Contests & Giveaways

People love to be a part of fun community activities, especially when rewards are involved. Contests and giveaways create excitement, engage your audience, and encourage participation, all while providing a chance to collect email addresses.

Contests and giveaways naturally generate excitement among your audience because people love the thrill of winning something that might seem limited or exclusive. Take to social media and organize a well-promoted contest or giveaway; include the reward item to be a highly valued item, such as a new product or something that surrounds your brand, like cooking equipment or a recipe book. Just make sure the prizes you’re offering align with your brand and are enticing enough to motivate people to participate. 

While getting creative and organizing contests and giveaways can grow your email list, we don’t recommend using it often as a marketing tool. Contests and giveaways can help grow your email list, but this doesn’t necessarily mean they are ideal customers. Utilize this strategy, but don’t rely on it to continue to grow your email list.

Grow Your Food Brand Example 10


Incorporating some or all of these ideas into your food brand’s marketing strategy can help you grow a successful email list. You can increase the number of subscribers and build a community of food lovers who are genuinely passionate about your brand. Building a quality email list takes time and effort, but using some practical strategies to cultivate customer relationships will be invaluable in the long run.

Need help to make these tactics a reality for your food brand? Look no further! Book a free 30 minute consultation with Spark Bridge Digital and learn what best tactics can be utlitized to foster a successful email list for your food brand.

Schedule Your Call

In our meeting together, we will run through your current email marketing setup, the hurdles you are facing, and more. At the end of our call, I’ll be able to detail how my team and I could help.

When booking, you’ll see a few questions that must be answered prior to our call. We are very selective about what brands and clients we work with to ensure we can succeed with your email marketing.